Monday, September 14, 2026

 Other Socrates but same way

The other Socrates is a philosopher with same name of more famous philosopher, may the first master of Aristotle, he is inserted from Plato(b.Ch.427-347) in dialogue of Sophist, it is the dialogue that encloses this other Socrates that certainly Plato has used for the name, since Plato has inserted in every his dialogue his master, Socrates(b.Ch.469-399); and Socrates gives to a member of dialogue a question, this member is a foreign, Socrates asked regard to way for to search the knowledge: “When do you explain  that you want demonstrate, are you usual speak you alone…or do you prefer give the precise question?”, and the foreign answers: “If is an interlocutor that is able of follow the dialogue is better, it is certain; but the contrary case I speak alone”; it is the philosophical habit of Socrates, that the foreign continues: “Dear Socrates it is the first time that I meet you and I don’t want leave occasion for a close confront, word to word…”; it is the method of Socrates that Plato, a his pupil, has known very well; in fact in this dialogue the foreign says to Theaetetus, a member of dialogue regard to method  necessary to inquiry the greater things is necessary begin from the small things, he asks to Theaetetus: “Do you want that we search an easy argument…and equally it needs of a right think, we consider the fisherman with fisher line…”; it is the Socratic simplicity, that from very easy matter he came to complicate matter; it is the diaretic way; it is a method that certainly Socrates has used, what is? Simple a subdivision of a elementary concept, that is divided  among the species his gender, this is the division of common gender, for example the humanity, that we find also in women, because also they are human gender; hence the human gender is divided between two species, and the relation between these two gender are evident; if we think the human nature that is common twice, men and women. The dialogue through the diaretical method follows his course, and Socrates uses the logic think, and he divided the fisherman from the other hunter, this is the Sophistic hunter, this is the hunter of men, it is the difference from the fisherman and the sophistic philosopher, that hunts the domestic animals this is the men; it is one reflex of the despise of Socrates to the Sophistic school, that in Apologize, this is the discourse of Socrates in court fro his defense, he hinted to philosophers that are paid  fro to sale the knowledge , this is the sophistic, in fact the foreign says that the technique of persuasion that was the way used form the Sophistic school. This dialogue is, in short,  the following  of Socrates’s accuse to Sophistic school. And the confirm of this thesis is in following words: “These is also the other side, that making profession of a determined competence it stablishes rapports that are for the teaching of virtue , but alone for to gain money. Also this side we must distinguish through a name.”, and Theaetetus answer: “Yes certain”, and the Foreign. “What name? you say it”, and the Theaetetus: “it is clear. I think that we are managed to find the sophist, and I am saying so I think that I name tit through the fit name.”; hence the polemical matter is right.    

 Alessandro Lusana    



No comments:

Post a Comment

  Other Socrates but same way The other Socrates is a philosopher with same name of more famous philosopher, may the first master of Arist...